top of page

Debunking Myths: Sustainable Investing and Returns

Before we dive headfirst into this domain, let's establish a common understanding of what sustainable investing truly entails. At its core, sustainable investing seeks to blend financial returns with positive societal and environmental impacts. It's about reconciling profits with principles, demonstrating that you can indeed have it all.

Myth #1: Trading Values for Returns

One of the staunch myths about sustainable investing suggests that prioritising environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors comes at the expense of financial returns. But hold on, we are about to debunk this myth and set the narrative straight.

Fact: ESG Integration Fuels Returns

Extensive research consistently shows that companies with robust ESG practices not only keep pace but often outperform their counterparts in financial performance. Consider this, as the world shifts toward renewable energy sources like wind and solar, profitability soars. Predictions indicate renewables will soon overtake coal as the world's primary electricity source, making sustainable energy investments exceptionally promising.

Moreover, corporate giants like Unilever and Tesla, once synonymous with unsustainable practices, are now ESG leaders, showcasing that profitability and sustainability are not adversaries; they're partners in progress.

The swell of ESG funds additionally demonstrates the financial potential of sustainable investing. Assets in sustainable mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) skyrocketed by an astounding 52 per cent from 2020 to the end of 2021, reaching a total of $362 billion. This incredible growth underscores investor confidence in sustainable investments and their capacity to deliver attractive returns.

A Long-Term Perspective: Experts preach the value of patience when it comes to investments. From this perspective, ESG-driven companies shine. By proactively addressing potential environmental and social risks, these firms exhibit resilience in the face of external shocks. Whether adapting to evolving regulations or navigating reputation challenges, their forward-thinking approach translates into superior returns over time.

Moreover, in a world increasingly attuned to sustainability, firms neglecting ESG factors may face regulatory fines and alienation from a consumer base that champions green values.

Myth #2: Sustainable Finance: A Fleeting Trend?

Let's address the notion that sustainable finance is just a passing trend. We discern between fads and lasting shifts in the financial landscape.

Fact: Sustainable Finance is Here to Stay

The trajectory of sustainable finance unmistakably indicates permanence, not sheer trendiness. Morningstar's data offers a vivid illustration: annual European sustainable fund flows surged from €50 billion in 2018 to a staggering €120 billion in 2019. Even amid the upheavals of the COVID-19 pandemic, 89% of sustainable indices outperformed broader market counterparts.

This resilience in times of crisis reflects the strength and foresight of companies with robust governance, sustainable cash flows, and a clear vision for the future. Sustainability isn't confined to corporate boardrooms or stock markets; it's a global movement.

International agreements like the Paris Agreement and the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) solidify sustainability's role in national and corporate strategies. Businesses now recognise that ESG metrics are not mere checkboxes; they are vital to long-term survival.

Prominent industry experts champion ESG investing. Their recognition of the opportunities ahead, especially in years without major distractions like U.S. elections, highlights ESG investing's surging popularity due to climate change and social justice concerns.

Moreover, instruments like the Natural Capital Protocol and the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosure guide businesses seeking to improve their ESG practices. These frameworks emphasise that sustainability encompasses not only environmental but also social and governance aspects.

Myth #3: Size Matters – Only Large Corporations Can Be Sustainable

Now, let's dismantle the belief that only large corporations can afford sustainability. We know that commitment, not size, determines a company's ability to embrace sustainability.

Fact: SMEs Pioneering Sustainability

Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) exert global significance. They comprise a whopping 90% of global businesses and generate two out of every three jobs worldwide. Their influence on global supply chains is undeniable.

SMEs do face resource limitations and knowledge constraints, but many are taking proactive steps to prioritise ESG issues. Rising ESG reporting standards and regulations mean that proactive SMEs can seize business opportunities and valuable partnerships.

In the UK, SMEs contribute over £2 trillion to the economy, playing a pivotal role in helping the nation achieve its Net Zero targets by 2050. A study by Lloyds Bank in 2021 revealed varying stages of Net Zero journeys among SMEs. Despite challenges, 95% of them are aware of the government's 2050 Net Zero objective, and many are taking concrete steps towards it.

SMEs are leveraging collaborations to achieve Net Zero. Around 56% have engaged with other businesses to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. SMEs in the UK that prioritise sustainability can avail benefits like cost savings, improved reputation, and new investments. Access to sustainable finance tools and resources is also becoming more accessible to SMEs. It's not the size of the business but the size of its commitment to sustainability that matters. SMEs worldwide are proving that sustainability is not the exclusive domain of large corporations.

Myth #4: Ignoring the "S" and "G" in ESG?

Now, let's address another common oversight in sustainable investing – the tendency to overemphasise the "E" (environmental) while sidelining the equally vital "S" (social) and "G" (governance) components of ESG. As finance experts, we understand the need for a balanced approach.

Fact: The "S" and "G" Are Crucial

Recently, the spotlight on environmental concerns, particularly climate change, has grown significantly. While addressing climate change is undoubtedly critical, experts underscore the dangers of neglecting the "S" and "G" facets of ESG.

The Human Element ("S")

The "S" in ESG embodies the essence of society and its people. It represents the human dimension of sustainability. A company's environmental efforts can't reach their full potential without an emphasis on the human element.

Governance as the Pillar ("G")

Governance, represented by the "G" in ESG, serves as the operational and ethical framework guiding an organisation. Robust governance ensures that ambitious environmental commitments translate into tangible actions. Without solid governance, even the most ambitious sustainability agendas can become mere rhetoric.

Interdependence of ESG

Just as a triangle requires all three sides to remain intact, the ESG framework operates as a triad. The absence or weakening of one component jeopardises the effectiveness of the others. Neglecting the "S" and "G" components can compromise a company's overall sustainability efforts.

A Cautionary Note on Over-Focusing on the "E"

While climate change takes centre stage, it should not overshadow other pressing ESG aspects. Actions aimed at combating climate change can sometimes inadvertently compromise social and governance standards. For example, the construction of massive solar farms might encroach upon the land rights of indigenous groups.

Moreover, the relentless focus on carbon reduction sometimes diverts attention from other critical environmental issues. The alarming decline in global insect populations, for instance, often takes a backseat in discussions dominated by carbon emissions.

A Way Forward: Holistic ESG Approach

Companies and institutions should prioritise all three components of ESG – environmental, social, and governance – equally. These organisations not only perform better financially, but they also attract the brightest talent and the most loyal customers. A holistic ESG approach isn't just about ticking boxes; it's about creating a sustainable future where every component thrives.

In the world of finance, where complexity often reigns, sustainable investing offers clarity and purpose. By placing equal importance on each pillar of ESG – environmental, social, and governance – companies, governments, and societies can pave the way for a sustainable future where financial prosperity goes hand in hand with positive societal and environmental impact. Sustainability isn't just a buzzword or trend; it's a holistic strategy for lasting and meaningful development.


bottom of page